Sole Proprietor vs (Pty) Ltd in South Africa

Read the full guide

Add your name and email and the full guide opens below. We email you a copy as well.

The two structures

A South African business can trade as a sole proprietor (you and the business are legally the same person) or through a private company, a (Pty) Ltd (a separate legal entity you own). The choice affects your liability, your tax and your admin.

Liability

As a sole proprietor there's no legal separation between you and the business. Business debts are your debts; if the business is sued, your personal assets are exposed. A (Pty) Ltd is a separate legal person, so business debts and claims stay with the company, provided you keep company and personal money apart and meet your duties as a director. For a business that could face large claims, this can decide the question on its own.

Tax

A sole proprietor's profit is taxed in your hands at personal income tax rates, which are progressive and climb to 45%. A company pays 27% corporate tax (or the lower Small Business Corporation rates if it qualifies), and then you're taxed again when you take profits out as dividends (20% dividends tax) or salary. At lower profits a sole proprietor can pay less tax and has less admin. As profits grow, a company can pay less, through SBC rates and by leaving profit in the business. We calculate the profit level at which the company becomes cheaper for you.

Admin and cost

A sole proprietor has the lighter load: no CIPC, no annual return, no separate company tax return, no beneficial ownership filing. A company carries all of that — CIPC annual returns, annual financial statements, an ITR14, beneficial ownership — and each of these costs time and fees. In return you get the liability protection and more choice over how profit is taxed.

Credibility and growth

A company can bring in co-owners and investors by issuing shares. If you plan to take on investors or tender for larger work, starting as a company saves moving the business across later.

Choosing a structure

A sole proprietorship suits a business with low profit and low risk. A (Pty) Ltd suits a business with liability exposure, growing profit, or plans to bring in partners or investors. We work out the figures for your business before you decide. See our company services if you're ready to incorporate.

Common questions

Can I switch from sole proprietor to a company later?

Yes. You incorporate a company and move the trade across. The move is simpler early on, so if you expect growth, consider incorporating sooner.

At what profit does a company become worthwhile?

There's no single figure — it depends on how much profit you leave in the business, whether you qualify as a Small Business Corporation, and your personal tax position. We set out the tax under both structures side by side, using your figures.

Is my personal money at risk as a sole proprietor?

Yes. Because there's no legal separation, business debts and claims can reach your personal assets. If your business could face large claims, a company protects your personal assets whatever the tax position.

Does a company always pay less tax?

No. At lower profits, a sole proprietor taxed at personal rates can pay less overall than a company plus dividends tax. The company's advantage grows with profit and with retaining earnings in the business. We calculate both for your figures.

Sole proprietor or (Pty) Ltd